Why won’t the England flag myth die already?

St. George slaying a dragon

St. George, the BNP's favourite mixed race Italian-Palestinian from Turkey.

Since science news is thin on the ground today, I want to talk about something else.

More than 1,200 housing association staff banned from flying England flags on their OWN cars” screams today’s Mail. Now, if you’ve read any tabloid paper recently, or even just visited Facebook, you’ll have seen the ridiculous myth that England shirts and flags have been banned by the police. The myth has been debunked by better bloggers than I, so I’m instead just going to talk about this one article.

You see, the housing association (Bolton At Home) hasn’t banned staff from flying flags on their own cars at all. They’ve banned them from flying them from officially branded cars and vehicles used while on official duty. Which is fair enough really; while I might not be offended should an official public body send round a car with England flags flapping from the bonnet, it’s hardly professional either – not to mention that flags cause a fair bit of drag, which of course reduces the vehicle’s fuel consumption by enough that public funds would be wasted having to fill up more often (the figures given in the article aren’t especially useful to do any meaningful maths with – they don’t say what the fuel consumption was to begin with – but still; half a litre per kilometre, their upper limit, is 4.7 mpg. By comparison, a Hummer H2 gets 8-12 mpg.)

But that’s not what I want to talk about.

The Daily Mail says that the regulation is in place because “decking out their personal vehicles with the St George’s flags could ‘discriminate’ against those who don’t support England during the World Cup” which, besides being a lovely example of scarequotes on the word discriminate, is quite obviously wrong. For one thing, all flags are banned, not just England ones – the article specifically mentions a case involving a complaint against a Bolton At Home worker flying the Irish flag as the reason for the regulation. In addition, it’s not about discrimination against people who aren’t England supporters, it’s about protecting people against whom nationalist symbols have been co-opted by the far-right as a weapon.

But that’s not what I want to talk about either.

No, I’m most interested in this quote:

Mark Perryman, head of the official England supporters club, said: ‘Banning the use of any flag is wrong and simply suppresses multiculturalism.

‘The idea that you can suppress something like this by diktat is ludicrous and incredibly badly thought out.

‘South Africa is a country with an appalling history – apartheid, famine, Aids, being badly treated by the empire – but everybody is flying the flag of the rainbow nation. People in England should be doing the same.’

Do you hear that, world? Refusing to fly a flag? Well, that’s worse than starvation, apartheid, AIDS and colonialism put together.

Advertisements

  1. #1 by ukenagashi on Thursday, 10th June 2010 - 13:37 UTC

    In addition, it’s not about discrimination against people who aren’t England supporters, it’s about protecting people against whom nationalist symbols have been co-opted by the far-right as a weapon.

    OH MY GOD, THANK YOU. I’ve been trying to put this into words for ages!

    • #2 by atomicspin on Thursday, 10th June 2010 - 13:50 UTC

      Yeah, it’s something that really pisses me off about the “Does the English flag offend you? Then get out of England!” crowd.

      The people who make those comments are not the ones who face constant attacks – both verbal and physical – from groups who wear the St. George Cross on their clothes, on their faces, and even on their skin as tattoos. In fact, often, the “But I just want to show my love for my country” concern trolls are the very people who’ve fomented this distrust and fear of nationalist and patriotic symbolism in the first place.

  2. #3 by wickedday on Friday, 11th June 2010 - 13:21 UTC

    Screwing with xenophobes is one of the better uses I’ve found for being Foreign While White ™. You let them dig a hole, and then tell the story of how grandma moved to England in 196o-something with her four baby immigrants, all of whom kept their foreign citizenship, are still fiercely patriotic for their country of birth, will take any opportunity to tell you about the innate sporting, culinary and weather-related superiority thereof, and are raising their children in their non-English heritage.

    And then watch them struggle to appear consistent without saying “… But it’s okay, ‘cos you’re white.” It’s the kind of thing that makes it starkly clear how often racism is the motive at the bottom of all this.

    Also, if you’re in a country voluntarily, you’ve probably gotten used to seeing the national flag here and there – we’re not as flag-happy as some places, but there’s a fair few Union Flags about the place. Odds-on that your average immigrant will be far less bothered by a stray England flag than your average hardline nationalist would be by a car flying, say, a Polish one.

  3. #4 by Chris on Saturday, 12th June 2010 - 9:32 UTC

    My favourite bit was “Banning the use of any flag is wrong and simply suppresses multiculturalism”

    Would waving Nazi flags in Israel be a wonderful sign of multiculturalism?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: